Metadata for Winter/Spring Wheat Growth Stage Models
The winter/spring wheat growth stage model is a heat-unit or growing degree-day (GDD) model in which wheat’s growth and development is based on the plant’s physiological response to temperature, photoperiodism, and vernalization. Both the spring and winter wheat stage models are initiated by assuming an average planting date, and accumulated GDD are then calculated and scaled according to wheat growth stages as defined by Ritchie (1991). In addition, GDD accumulations for the entire growing season are variety specific, with spring or winter variety greatly influencing the plant’s response to vernalization (cold temperature) and photoperiod (day length) requirements during the emergence stage.
Both the spring and winter wheat models are based on the Ritchie (1991) wheat growth model with the following phenological stages defined as:
|
Stage No. |
Phenological State |
1 |
Emergence to terminal spikelet. |
2 |
Terminal spikelet to End of vegetative growth. |
3 |
End of veg growth to End of pre-anthesis ear growth. |
4 |
End of pre-anthesis ear growth to Beginning of grain fill. (Anthesis occurs during this phase) |
5 |
Beginning of grain fill to Physiological maturity. |
6 |
Physiological maturity to fallow (harvest). |
7 |
Fallow to sowing (time after harvest to planting) |
8 |
Sowing to Germination. |
9 |
Germination to Emergence. |
The Ritchie wheat model is then converted to the Robertson (1968) Biometeorological Time Scale (BMTS) according to the following Ritchie-BMTS conversion table (first two columns), with corresponding approximate GDD accumulations (last two columns):
Ritchie |
Robertson |
Phenological State |
GDD |
Approx. Accumulated GDD3. |
7.0-8.0 |
0.0-0.0001 |
Pre-planting |
|
|
8.0-9.0 |
0.0001-0.1 |
Planting |
|
|
9.0-9.9 |
0.1-1.0 |
Germination |
70 |
70 |
1.0-2.0 |
1.0-1.3 |
Emergence1. |
330 |
400 |
2.0-2.5 |
1.3-2.0 |
Tillering |
285 |
685 |
2.5-3.0 |
2.0-3.0 |
Stem |
|
|
3.0-4.0 |
3.0-3.6 |
Booting |
190 |
875 |
4.0-5.0 |
3.6-4.0 |
Flowering |
200 |
1075 |
5.0-5.3 |
4.0-4.5 |
Milky |
|
|
5.3-6.0 |
4.5-5.0 |
Waxy Ripe2. |
450-530 |
1575 |
6.0-7.0 |
5.0-5.13 |
Maturity |
250 |
1825 |
- Photoperiod (day length) and vernalization (cold temperature) requirements can slow down the emergence stage (Ritchie Stage 1) and are dependent on genotype.
- Total GDD accumulations during the grain-filling period (Ritchie stage 5) are variety specific, with short season varieties requiring less accumulated GDD units than long season varieties and total GDD heat units ranging from 450-530 GDD.
- GDD accumulations in the above table are based on Celsius degree-days, which are not the same as Fahrenheit degree-days because a Fahrenheit degree is smaller than a Celsius degree. It therefore takes nine Fahrenheit degree-days to make five Celsius degree-days, or GDDc = 5/9 (GDDf) and correspondingly GDDf = 9/5 (GDDc).
GDD heat units are calculated each day by averaging minimum and maximum daily temperatures and subtracting a base temperature of 0-degree Celsius (32-degree Fahrenheit). The accumulated GDD heat units drive the Ritchie wheat growth model, but plant growth during the emergence stage can be slowed down depending on the wheat variety and its sensitivity towards photoperiodism and vernalization.
Photoperiodism and vernalization are described below, with additional GDD information presented in the metadata section for the corn growth stage model.
Photoperiodism and Vernalization
Both photoperiod and vernalization influence leaf numbers and plant growth for winter and spring wheat varieties.
Photoperiod is the length of time a plant is exposed to daylight, whereby wheat is a long-day plant, meaning it develops more rapidly and makes fewer leaves during long days. Photoperiod in the wheat growth model is defined as the relative amount that plant development is slowed (and more leaves formed) during a shorter photoperiod than the optimum photoperiod, whereby the optimum photoperiod is assumed as 20 hours of daylight.
Photoperiod types are classified as PS, which require long days for timely flowering; or photoperiod insensitive (PI), which can be grown successfully in both long or short day environments. Photoperiod response is of interest to plant breeders in northern latitudes because new PI cultivars can grow faster, reduce risk of frost damage, and maintain or improve yields relative to PS wheat varieties (Dyck, et al, 2004). In all environments, PI cultivars tend to reduce tillering, reduce plant height, and reduce spikelets per spike, which correspondingly accelerates time to heading and maturity.
Vernalization also influences leaf numbers and it is the wheat plant’s response to relatively cold temperatures that must occur before reproductive growth will begin. Vernalization is assumed to occur at temperatures between 0 and 18 C, with the optimum temperature for vernalization in the range of 0 and 7 C and with temperatures between 7 and 18 C having less influence on the process. For winter wheat, the low temperature requirement for vernalization begins at germination and exposure to relatively low temperatures is required before spikelet formation can begin.
Spring-type winter cereals have little sensitivity to vernalization, which is the principal difference between spring and the winter wheat types. There are also intermediate, or facultative, wheat varieties that have varying degrees of sensitivity to vernalization.
Even though there is a genetic variability in sensitivity to vernalization, 50 vernalization days are assumed to be sufficient to completely vernalize all cultivars. Plant development is slowed (and more leaves formed) for each day of unfulfilled vernalization, whereby 50-days of vernalization is assumed to be sufficient for all cultivars.
Available Wheat Varieties within the Wheat Growth Model
The current winter and spring wheat growth stage models have the following wheat varieties and coefficients:
Type |
Variety |
Name |
P1V1 |
P1D2 |
P53 |
Winter |
2 |
Centurk |
6.0 |
2.5 |
470 |
Winter |
3 |
Scott |
6.0 |
3.5 |
470 |
Winter |
4 and 5 |
Mironovskaya/Bezostaya |
6.0 |
2.9 |
530 |
Spring |
1 and A |
Ellar/Yamil |
0.5 |
2.7 |
470 |
Spring |
6 |
Mexipak |
0.5 |
2.4 |
470 |
Spring |
7 |
Sonalika |
0.5 |
1.6 |
470 |
Spring |
9 |
Egret |
0.5 |
3.0 |
470 |
Facultative |
B |
Generic |
3.6 |
3.2 |
500 |
- P1V is the Vernalization Coefficient used to calculate vernalization in Stage 1. The scaled values of P1V range from 0 to 8, with
1 being no vernalization for spring wheat varieties,
3 being intermediate varieties
6 being most winter wheat varieties and having approximately 50 vernalization days
8 having very long vernalization duration
- P1D is the Photoperiod Day Length Coefficient used to calculate photoperiod sensitivity in Stage 1. The scaled values of P1D range from 1 to 5, where 1 is insensitive and a value of 5 is highly sensitive to photoperiodism. Highly sensitive photoperiod varieties are grown in the northern areas of North America and Europe.
- P5 is the GDD value used for the grain filling stage from flowering to maturity. This value varies amongst genotypes and ranges from 450-530 GDD.
The proper wheat variety for a region should first be selected based on winter, spring, or facultative wheat varieties grown in the region. For example, farmers plant winter wheat varieties if cold temperatures during the growing season are typically below freezing after planting wheat. In contrast, farmers plant spring wheat varieties if normal temperatures typically remain above freezing throughout the entire growing season. Finally, facultative wheat varieties are typically planted in climates where temperatures may reach below freezing temperatures during some years, but not for all years.
In the past, photoperiod sensitive (PS) cultivars provided good yield stability, local adaptation, and high productivity in northern areas of North America and Europe, with plant breeders developing and providing more PI cultivars in recent years. Hucl (1995) reported that before the mid-1980s virtually all Canada Western Red Spring (CWRS) wheat cultivars were photoperiod sensitive (PS), but currently PI varieties comprise about 20 percent of CWRS wheat (Dyck, et al, 2004). In Europe, Foulkes (2004) reported that most wheat varieties grown in southern and mainland Europe are PI because of their wider adaptation, relative to PS cultivars, while varieties in the UK are mostly PS. Correspondingly, PI cultivars have been shown to have a 30% yield advantage over PS cultivars in southern European regions, 15% in mainland regions, and no yield advantage in the UK (Worland et al., 1994).
References:
Dyck, J.A., Matus-Cadiz, M.A., Hucl, P., Talbert, L., Hunt, T., Dubuc, J.P., Nass, H., Clayton, G., Dobb, J., Quick, J. 2004. Agronomic performance of hard red spring wheat isolines sensitive and insensitive to photoperiod. Crop Science, Nov-Dec, 2004
Foulkes, M.J., R. Sylvester-Bradley, A.J. Worland, and J.W. Snape. 2004. Effects of a photoperiod-response gene Ppd-Dl on yield potential and drought resistance in UK winter wheat. Euphytica 135:63-73.
Hucl, P. 1995. Growth response of four hard red spring wheat cultivars to date of seeding. Can. J. Plant Sci. 75:75-80.
Ritchie, J.T.1991. Wheat phasic development. p. 31-54. In Hanks and Ritchie (ed.) Modeling Plant and Soil Systems. Agronomy Monograph 31, ASA, CSSSA, SSSA, Madison, WI.
Robertson, G.W. 1968. A Biometeorological Time Scale for a Cereal Crop Involving Day and Night Temperatures and Photoperiod. Intern J. Biometeor. 12:191-223.
Worland, A.J. 1996. The influence of flowering time genes on environmental adaptability in European wheats. Euphytica 89:49-57.